Paternity fraud is a complex and emotionally charged issue within the realm of family law, often carrying substantial financial ramifications. It occurs when a woman deliberately misidentifies the biological father of her child, leaving an unsuspecting man to believe he is the father. This deception can have far-reaching effects, particularly concerning child support obligations. Effectively navigating the financial consequences of paternity fraud is of utmost importance for all parties involved, as it directly impacts the falsely named father and the overall well-being of the child. In this article, we delve into the intricate web of financial implications, legal considerations, and potential solutions when faced with paternity fraud cases
A 44-year-old man broke down in tears during a live radio interview after DNA test showed he is not the father of all the kids his wife bore for him. The man and his wife have 4 children together aged 16, 12, and two other kids aged 8 and 5 years respectively.
DNA test was conducted on all 4 kids at the DDC DNA Diagnositic centre in Alakoko, Osogbo, and the result showed that the man is not the biological father of any of the kids.
“Nigeria ranks high in paternity fraud. The current statistic for this puts Nigeria as the second highest in the world with around 30% of cases of paternity fraud in the population after Jamaica” Abasi Ene-Obong, CEO and Co-founder of Stack Diagnostics tells Pulse.
Many men have been unknowingly raising children that are not theirs and to curb the trend, there have been calls for introduction of mandatory DNA testing at birth
“The issue of paternity is a trilogy. It’s moral, scientific and legal issue,” a concerned commentator noted. “Series of DNA tests carried out in laboratories are showing that a number of children are being fathered by men who are not their biological fathers.”
The 30% statistic (or 3 out of 10 Nigerian fathers) is not new. Within the last couple of years, this statistic has bubbled to the surface in social media conversations.
If a man is led to believe by a woman that he is the father of her child when he is not, and the woman knows that he is not, this is paternity fraud. In limited circumstances, he may be able to bring a claim for damages if he has paid money to maintain the child because of the deceit.
Paternity fraud is suspected to be a widespread issue. While it is impossible to estimate exactly how many men are unknowingly raising a child that is not theirs biologically, it could be a substantial number.
Some men are able to continue to father the child and concentrate on having a loving relationship with them after finding out the truth. However, in some cases the deception is distressing, they want compensation for what has happened, and for the money they have paid to maintain the child. This is more likely to be the case if the purported father’s relationship with the mother has broken down.
Misattributed paternity can be devastating for men who have spent years believing they are biologically tied to a child, only to later learn that they actually share no DNA. Paternity fraud causes immense emotional pain and turmoil, affecting the biological father, the non-biological father, the mother, and the child at the center of it. Also, victims of misattributed paternity may have been paying child support for years.
Once the truth is revealed, it is rarely a simple matter to be reimbursed for those payments. Here’s how paternity fraud happens and what you can do if you’ve been paying child support for a child you did not father.
What Is Paternity Fraud?
Paternity fraud occurs when the mother of a child misidentifies a man as the biological father of their child.1 Sometimes, the mother knows that the man is not biologically linked to the child. In other cases, they may not know for sure or only suspect that the child is not genetically linked to the father they named on the birth certificate.
How Does Paternity Fraud Happen?
Paternity fraud generally happens when a man is asked to sign an affidavit of paternity for a child with whom they share no biological connection. Presumably, in such cases, it is the mother who is urging the man to sign the affidavit or birth certificate form. The issue is then complicated when the state uses that affidavit or birth certificate as proof of paternity in a child support case, instead of ordering an actual DNA test before assigning child support.
In some states, paternity fraud also happens through a process known as “the presumption of paternity.”2 This happens when a person is designated by the state as the child’s biological father simply because they and the mother were married at the time of the child’s birth or conception.
An actual law in some states, the presumption of paternity causes some men to pay child support on behalf of children they are not related to—in some cases, even long after the misattributed paternity is apparent.
When Paternity Fraud Is Revealed
Paternity fraud often goes undetected for years. Sometimes, it comes to light after medical records reveal that the child cannot possibly be related to the man attributed as the biological father.3
In cases where paternity fraud has resulted in child support payments, the court is left to decide whether those payments should continue. While it seems on the surface that the obvious answer is “no,” the court’s focus is always on the best interests of the child. As such, the court may:
- Cease further child support payments, or
- Order a continuation of child support payments
Paternity Fraud’s Impact on Child Support
A court may order a father who is not the biological parent of a child to continue child support payments because:1
- Continued child support payments serve the best interests of the child.
- The child still needs to be supported and the court believes the child may require government assistance if child support payments cease.
- The father has supported the child for a period of time and has acted as the child’s father.
Help for Victims of Paternity Fraud
Men who are victims of paternity fraud should attempt to seek action in civil court to collect child support funds back from the child’s parent Unfortunately, reimbursement is generally considered a long shot.
Consequences of Paternity Fraud
Unfortunately, there are currently no legal consequences for mothers who commit paternity fraud.3 Paternity fraud is not considered a punishable crime, and it’s extremely difficult to collect or recollect funds from the child’s mother.
What To Do When You Are The Victim of Paternity Fraud
With so many paternity tests readily available, suspicions of paternity fraud are easier than ever to confirm. However, just because your gut feeling turned out to be true and you are not the biological father of the child doesn’t necessarily mean you will find relief within the family law court system.
If you later learn you are the victim of paternity fraud, it is not as easy as submitting the DNA test results to the court to eliminate a child support order.
Depending on the jurisdiction, once the deadlines for contesting paternity have passed and the court has ordered terms for support, you may still be obligated to continue to support the child despite the fact that a DNA test has proven you are not the father. In fact, many states have declared that a DNA test alone is not sufficient to vacate a paternity order.
If the child’s biological father cannot be found and produced, the courts may completely overlook the victimization and turn to the best interest of the child, which is to continue to require you to support the child.
There is hope, though, even if the deadline for contesting paternity has passed.
The court may vacate a paternity acknowledgement if you prove fraud, duress, or material mistake of fact. However, the difficulty in proving fraud, duress, or material mistake of fact to vacate the acknowledgment is that the laws and court rulings of each state vary so be sure to consult with a licensed attorney.
In order to prove paternity fraud, you must prove that the mother actually committed fraud. The elements of fraud require you to prove that she knew you were not the father, she told you that you were the father, and that you signed the acknowledgment based on her statement. This is not to be confused with a woman who mistakenly names you the biological father though it later turns out that you are not the father. Fraud must be present.
To prove fraud, you will need evidence. Did she tell you she knew? Did she write you a letter or e-mail stating she knew? Did she tell anyone that she knew? These are just a few of the questions that you will need answered in order to gather evidence to assemble your case.
In addition to proving the child is not yours and the mother willingly and knowingly committed fraud when naming you the father, you must also identify and then locate the child’s actual biological father. As mentioned earlier, the courts are concerned that the child has financial support and if you can find the biological father than the courts have alternative means of support for the child that doesn’t require you.
In some jurisdictions, you may be able to obtain an order requiring the biological father reimburse you for the amount you have already paid in support.
Even if you do not believe you have a case for fraud, if you believe you are not the father of a child you have been ordered to pay support for, you should contact a domestic litigation attorney licensed in your jurisdiction.
If you have had a paternity test, it’s as accurate an answer you will get – with 99.99% certainty. But for men who discover they have grown-up children they never knew about, it can be devastating emotionally. For some men, a positive paternity test triggers terrible feelings of guilt.
Dealing with Guilt
Guilt can be the overriding emotion when you discover you have a grown-up child you never knew about. A paternity test could uncover children who were a result of an affair or liaison. And finding out later in life when they’ve already done their growing up can leave fathers feeling a sense of all-consuming guilt. This can be made worse if their offspring tell them of times in their childhood they were unhappy, felt let down or had something negative occur. The instinct for a father is to protect his offspring, and not being there for their children in their time of need can leave unresolved guilt. A DNA test may bring joy for some, but it can leave a minefield of emotions for others.
Uncover the Truth
For some men who have their own family, they may feel it necessary to keep the DNA test results a secret. But keeping a grown-up child a secret from your family can simply increase the feelings of guilt – especially if that child was a result of an extra-marital affair. One recent story highlighted how easy it is for children to track down their true fathers. The father had an affair and impregnated his lover, she then married and the couple brought up the son as their own and had two more children. But during a blazing row with the boy’s stepfather the truth came out. As a result the boy, then in his twenties, tracked down his father and had a paternity test.
Psychological Fall Out
For the father, he felt nothing but guilt but feared the revelation would destroy his family so kept it under wraps. Initially, he was in complete denial but a paternity test meant he couldn’t ignore the facts. He faced up to the shock after seeing a photo of his son and realised that even without a paternity DNA test, he was clearly his. Now father and son meet occasionally in secret and in fear, and as well as guilt on the father’s side, the son feels residual resentment. Clinical psychologists argue that anyone who discovers a biological relationship as a result of a DNA test should be honest and open about their expectations and emotions in order to build a healthy relationship. Keeping a paternity test secret and furtive can result in quite a lot of psychological damage for both parties.
Paternity fraud is a complex issue where a woman intentionally misidentifies the biological father of her child, leading an unsuspecting man to believe he is the father. This deception can have profound consequences, both legally and emotionally, for all parties involved. Understanding paternity fraud is essential to navigate its financial implications within the context of family law.
Paternity fraud can manifest in various forms, such as falsely accusing a man of fathering her child to secure financial support or to maintain a relationship. The motivations behind paternity fraud can range from financial gain and emotional manipulation to protecting personal relationships or avoiding social stigma. Legal frameworks and societal norms often assume that biological fathers bear financial responsibility for their children. However, paternity fraud challenges this assumption by potentially imposing financial obligations on individuals who are not biologically related to the child. Ethically, paternity fraud raises questions regarding truthfulness, accountability, and the rights of all parties involved, including the child, the falsely named father, and the biological father.
Establishing paternity is a fundamental aspect of family law, particularly for child support purposes. Genetic testing, such as DNA analysis, is a reliable method used to establish paternity accurately. However, in cases tainted by paternity fraud, these processes may be compromised, requiring careful examination and consideration of the evidence.
Challenges arise when paternity fraud taints the process of establishing paternity, as evidence may be manipulated or concealed by the woman. The legal system must carefully evaluate the evidence presented, conduct thorough investigations if necessary, and make impartial judgments regarding paternity.
Navigating the process of establishing paternity in cases tainted by paternity fraud requires sensitivity, thoroughness, and a commitment to justice. Legal professionals, genetic testing experts, and other relevant parties play a crucial role in uncovering the truth and ensuring the child’s best interests are upheld.
Legal Implications
If your wife comes to you with the news that she is pregnant with your child, you may feel excited, nervous or surprised. But what should you do if you find out later that you are not the true father of the child? You may learn that the mother committed paternity fraud. This sometimes occurs when a married woman wants to hide an extramarital affair that results in a pregnancy. In Illinois, it may be difficult to prove paternity fraud, but there are a few steps you may take if you suspect you are not the child’s father.
Determining the true parentage of a child is essential because it may have a significant impact on legal rights and responsibilities as well as financial issues. According to some state law in USA, if you were married to the child’s mother within 300 days of the child’s birth, the law presumes you to be the father. If you are not in fact the child’s biological father but your wife does not suggest that there is another potential father, she may be deliberately committing paternity fraud.
If you suspect your wife has committed paternity fraud, there are a few actions you may take. You may file a legal form to declare the non-existence of a parent-child relationship between yourself and the child. According to the law, you must initiate this action within two years of learning the relevant facts relating to paternity. For example, if you learn through a DNA test that you are not the child’s father, you must initiate the legal action within two years of receiving the test results. If the court agrees that you are not the child’s father, you may stop being subject to child support requirements and similar legal orders.
Paternity fraud involves a falsely named father providing financial support to a child who is not biologically his, including medical, education, and living expenses. This can lead to financial strain on the father, potentially hindering his financial stability and future prospects. The child may also be deprived of financial support from their biological father, affecting their well-being, educational opportunities, and overall quality of life. The emotional toll on the father and child can be significant, with feelings of betrayal, anger, and confusion.
Navigating the financial consequences of paternity fraud requires careful consideration and legal intervention. The father may seek legal advice and representation to assess options available to mitigate the financial burden imposed on him. Modifying child support orders and financial arrangements may be pursued to ensure a fair distribution of financial responsibility. In cases where paternity fraud is established, the father may pursue legal remedies to recover financial damages caused by the fraud.
Addressing the financial consequences of paternity fraud requires understanding the psychological and emotional toll experienced by both the father and the child. Support networks, counseling services, and therapeutic interventions can help individuals cope with the emotional aftermath and navigate the financial implications. By acknowledging and addressing the financial consequences of paternity fraud, the legal system can strive to achieve fair outcomes that protect the best interests of the child, ensure financial stability for all parties involved, and foster a sense of justice and equity in family law cases.
Family courts and child support agencies play crucial roles in adjudicating paternity fraud cases, ensuring fairness and justice for all parties involved. Legal professionals are essential in navigating these cases, guiding the falsely named father through the legal process and advocating for their interests. Emotional and psychological aspects of paternity fraud cases must also be addressed, with support networks, counseling services, and therapeutic interventions available to help the father and child cope. Raising awareness about the prevalence and impact of paternity fraud is essential, as it promotes understanding of available legal remedies and prevents future instances.
Mitigating the financial consequences of paternity fraud is essential to address the inequities and challenges faced by the father and child involved. Legal avenues for financial mitigation include modifying child support orders, seeking reimbursement, protecting the child’s financial interests, considering special circumstances, retroactive adjustments, and offering financial counseling and support services. Legislative reforms and public awareness campaigns can strengthen legal protections and promote fair outcomes in paternity fraud cases. Overall, a comprehensive approach that combines legal expertise, emotional support, and awareness is crucial for a fair and just resolution.
Paternity fraud is a complex issue in family law that can have significant financial consequences. To address this, mediation and alternative dispute resolution mechanisms can be employed, such as arbitration or collaborative law. These methods aim to reach mutually agreeable solutions that consider the best interests of the child and the financial circumstances of the falsely named father.
Mitigating the financial consequences of paternity fraud requires a multifaceted approach that combines legal remedies, policy considerations, and supportive services. Fair and equitable measures, such as modifying child support orders, seeking reimbursement, and identifying the biological father’s financial responsibility, can alleviate the financial burdens faced by the falsely named father. Additionally, protecting the child’s financial interests and providing necessary support can contribute to their well-being and future prospects.
Ethical considerations surrounding paternity fraud are crucial for fostering a just and equitable family law system. These include respecting individual autonomy, ensuring voluntary acknowledgment, protecting the child’s emotional and psychological well-being, ensuring financial support and stability, holding those responsible for paternity accountable, and maintaining integrity in family law.
Future implications and preventive measures include legislative reforms, education campaigns, and ethical responsibilities of legal professionals. By prioritizing fairness, individual rights, and the well-being of all involved, society can work towards a just and equitable resolution of paternity fraud cases.
Sources
It is in reality a nice and useful piece of info. I’m happy that you simply shared this helpful information with us. Please stay us up to date like this. Thanks for sharing.